Geo-mapping of caries risk in children and adolescents - a novel approach for allocation of preventive care
© Strömberg et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2011
Received: 24 May 2011
Accepted: 26 September 2011
Published: 26 September 2011
Dental caries in children is unevenly distributed within populations with a higher burden in low socio-economy groups. Thus, tools are needed to allocate resources and establish evidence-based programs that meet the needs of those at risk. The aim of the study was to apply a novel concept for presenting epidemiological data based on caries risk in the region of Halland in southwest Sweden, using geo-maps.
The study population consisted of 46,536 individuals between 3-19 years of age (75% of the eligible population) from whom caries data were reported in 2010. Reported dmfs/DMFS>0 for an individual was considered as the primary caries outcome. Each study individual was geo-coded with respect to his/her residence parish. A parish-specific relative risk (RR) was calculated as the observed-to-expected ratio, where the expected number of individuals with dmfs/DMFS>0 was obtained from the age- and sex-specific caries (dmfs/DMFS>0) rates for the total study population. Smoothed caries risk geo-maps, along with corresponding statistical certainty geo-maps, were produced by using the free software Rapid Inquiry Facility and the ESRI® ArcGIS system.
The geo-maps of preschool children (3-6 years), schoolchildren (7-11 years) and adolescents (12-19 years) displayed obvious geographical variations in caries risk, albeit most marked among the preschoolers. Among the preschool children the smoothed relative risk (SmRR) varied from 0.33 to 2.37 in different parishes. With increasing age, the contrasts seemed to diminish although the gross geographical risk pattern persisted also among the adolescents (SmRR range 0.75-1.20).
Geo-maps based on caries risk may provide a novel option to allocate resources and tailor supportive and preventive measures within regions with sections of the population with relatively high caries rates.
Keywordscaries children prevention geo-mapping
In spite of the global decline in childhood caries, widening inequalities in oral health exist between social classes and certain minority ethnic groups [1, 2]. In the United Kingdom, this has primarily been observed among preschool- and schoolchildren [3, 4]. Also in Scandinavia, where almost all children and adolescents attend the prevention-oriented free public dental service, a social gradient for dental health is evident [5–7]. In order to reduce these gaps, various oral health promotion activities has been suggested and, preferable, integrated with general health education since oral diseases and chronic systemic diseases share many common risk factors [8, 9]. The challenge and crucial decision for policymakers and professionals are to allocate resources and establish evidence-based programs that meet the needs of the vulnerable children at risk for caries. The allocation is traditionally based on conventional caries epidemiological data in spite of the fact that the children by then already are diseased. Oral health programs based on caries risk would be more proactive since a comprehensive risk assessment is an essential component in the decision-making process for the prevention and management of dental caries . Thus, the aims of the present communication were to suggest a novel approach to present epidemiological data based on caries risk in a population. We launch the use of geo-maps and apply the concept in the southwest Swedish region of Halland.
The Halland region has approximately 70,000 inhabitants below the age of 20 years and the vast majority is listed as regular patients at the Public Dental Service that provides free dental care between 1 and 19 years with recall intervals varying from 3 to 24 months depending on the individual need. Data on the experience of manifest (dentin) caries is registered according to the WHO-criteria  and annually reported to the community dentistry unit. The present study population included 46,536 individuals for whom caries data were reported in year 2010; they were between 3-19 years old when examined. The overall coverage was 75% of the total 3-19-year population of the region. The remaining children were not recalled for a regular check-up that year or visited a private dentist outside the region. In Halland, the fluoride concentration in piped water supply is low (<0.3 ppm) except in the northern part (the municipality of Kungsbacka) where the natural fluoride content is approximately 1.0 ppm. There is also a geographical variation in socio-economic characteristics of the population in the Halland region. For example, the proportion with post-secondary education among all residents varies between 10 to 48% across different parishes (data from year 2010 provided from Statistics Sweden). The study was approved by the Halland Hospital Ethical committee as well as The Swedish Data Inspection Board.
Geographical information system (GIS) methods
Epidemiological and statistical methods
Reported dmfs/DMFS >0 for an individual was considered as the primary caries outcome. A parish-specific relative risk (RR) was calculated as the observed-to-expected ratio, where the expected number of individuals with dmfs/DMFS >0 was obtained from the age- and sex-specific caries (dmfs/DMFS >0) rates for the whole region of Halland or, more precisely, for the total study population. The following age strata were used: 3-6, 7-11,12-18, and 19 years. Thus, the expected number for a parish equals the sum of the products n i ×r i across the age- and sex-strata i(3-6 year old girls; 3-6 year old boys; 7-11 year old girls; etc.), where n i denotes the stratum-specific number of study individuals residing in the parish and r i denotes the corresponding caries rate observed in the total study population. The computations of the RRs were performed using the free software Rapid Inquiry Facility , which provides an extension to ESRI® ArcGIS functions . The Rapid Inquiry Facility (RIF) along with free software for Bayesian data analyses, WinBUGS , provides a powerful tool for geo-mapping based on epidemiological data. The caries risk maps show the smoothed RRs (SmRR) for each parish, which were obtained by running the Bayesian hierarchical mapping model in RIF/WinBUGS. We underline that such Bayesian smoothing yields pronounced downward adjustment of a (conventional) RR for a parish with few study persons, estimated with relatively high uncertainty, if that RR turns out notably elevated. Hence, by presenting smoothed caries risk geo-maps, rational adjustments of the conventional (parish-specific) RRs are taken into account [15, 16].
We present separate caries risk geo-maps for preschool children (3-6 years), schoolchildren (7-11 years) and adolescents [12-19 years; based on age-stratified (12-18 and 19 years, respectively) analysis]. Along with each caries risk geo-map, we provide the corresponding statistical certainty geo-map. A posterior probability of a parish-specific relative risk above one given the data, denoted Pr(RR>1|data), was obtained by the Bayesian approach. A parish with data yielding strong statistical evidence of an elevated caries risk, more precisely Pr(RR>1|data) > 0.95, was colored red in the certainty geo-map. By contrast, a parish with evidently low caries risk, Pr(RR<1|data) > 0.95, was colored green. Analogously, parish-specific 90% credibility intervals for the relative risk were obtained; and each parish with a 90% credibility interval that covers 1 was colored yellow in the certainty geo-map indicating a weaker statistical evidence for a high or low relative risk in such parishes.
We addressed geographical co-variations between caries risk and residents'' level of education by calculating Spearman''s correlations (rS) between the SmRRs and the proportions with post-secondary educational level among the residents (considered as a group-level indicator of socio-economy) across the 66 parishes.
Prevalence and experience of manifest (dentin) caries on surface level in the Region of Halland 2010
Dmfs/DMFS = 0
Mean dmfs/DMFS (95% CI)
It is generally recognized that GIS may play an essential role in helping public health organizations understand population health and make decisions . The methods we applied have previously been utilized, e.g. within general medicine for risk mapping of common chronic diseases . However, dental caries is also a common chronic disease and it is evident that severe caries in childhood affects the quality of life. It is also clear that the skew burden of the disease calls for allocation of resources and manpower for preventive activities among those with the highest need. To our knowledge, the GIS concept has not previously been used within dentistry in the present manner. We have noticed close similarities with geo-maps based on some other diseases and medical conditions with life-style and behavior-related determinants, which is interesting. Thus, by addressing the common risk factor approach (high-sugar diet, fats, smoking, alcohol, lack of control, etc), dental professionals will not only prevent dental diseases but will also contribute to preventing obesity, heart disease and diabetes . The co-morbidity of the chronic dental and medical conditions is strong argument for the allocation of monetary and human resources according to the "directed vulnerable population strategy" (DVPS) that may be cost saving in the long perspective .
From an international perspective, it should be pointed out that the overall cumulative caries burden in the present study population was very low (Table 1) . Although the social and fluoride gradients on caries risk were quite expected, the produced geo-maps certainly provided some interesting and useful information for oral health planners. Educational level was considered a valid, objective socioeconomic indicator in this study area; it is also a parish-level measure that has been stable during recent years. In general, the educational level is higher in the urban residential areas and lower in the rural areas. Within the urban areas (located along coastline in the west) the social gradient could be explained by other factors such as family income and proportion of immigrants. The social gradient could be elaborated more in detail. Additional data on contextual/geographic and individual variables that are related to the caries outcome could allow for more extensive multilevel modeling. Nevertheless, investigators should consider adjustments for contextual and individual predictors with caution, depending on their purpose being to disclose vulnerable groups or provide further insights regarding the underlying predictors. Indeed, a quick glance at the present geo-maps could assist in making policies for reducing dental caries in vulnerable groups. For example, in the centre of the low-risk high-fluoride Kungsbacka municipality in the northern part of the region, an urban parish (1,334 study persons) with a notably higher caries risk among pre- and schoolchildren was identified (Figures 2 and 3). Schools and nurseries are excellent arenas to promote a healthy lifestyle and self-care practices in children . Therefore, a local school-based fluoride and healthy-habit activity could be implemented in such a parish; fluorides have been proven to be effective in controlling and preventing caries and are a vital component of all caries prevention programs [22–24].
Another interesting example was the demonstrated age-related impact of the smoothed relative risk which may imply that a relatively larger proportion of the preventive efforts should be steered towards the youngest age groups. Among the preschoolers, the SmRRs captured the geographical risk pattern of early childhood caries. There are several documented examples of successful programs for infant feeding and early fluoride exposure that have reduced inequalities in oral health in preschool children in a cost effective way . In the light of the examples given above, the suggested geo-maps may be an additional tool for allocation of necessary resources to dental practitioners to act as health advocates and monitor out-reach interventions performed by auxiliary staff. Among the adolescents, who have pronounced cumulative caries burden (Table 1), complementary measures to the SmRR (considering also mean dmfs/DMS) might be taken into account as well, in order to better capturing the geographical contrasts in caries burden.
In summary, geo-maps based on caries risk may provide a novel option to allocate resources and tailor supportive and preventive measures within regions with sections of the population with relatively high caries rates.
The authors are grateful to the smooth cooperation with the Public Dental Service in Halland and to Mr. Ralf Rittner for constructing the maps. The study was financially supported by Region Halland, Sweden.
- Locker D: Deprivation and oral health: a review. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2000, 28: 161-169. 10.1034/j.1600-0528.2000.280301.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sabbah W, Tsakos G, Chandola T, Sheiham A, Watt RG: Social gradients in oral and general health. J Dent Res. 2007, 86: 992-996. 10.1177/154405910708601014.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bedi R, Quarrell I, Kippen A: The dental health of 10-year-old children attending multi-racial schools in Greater Glasgow. Br Dent J. 1991, 170: 182-185. 10.1038/sj.bdj.4807466.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Conway DI, Quarrell I, McCall DR, Gilmour H, Bedi R, Macpherson LM: Dental caries in 5-year-old children attending multi-ethnic schools in Greater Glasgow--the impact of ethnic background and levels of deprivation. Community Dent Health. 2007, 24: 161-165.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Christensen LB, Twetman S, Sundby A: Oral health in children and adolescents with different socio-cultural and socio-economic backgrounds. Acta Odontol Scand. 2010, 68: 34-42. 10.3109/00016350903301712.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Skeie MS, Espelid I, Skaare AB, Gimmestad A: Caries patterns in an urban preschool population in Norway. Eur J Paediatr Dent. 2005, 6: 16-22.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wendt LK, Hallonsten AL, Koch G: Oral health in pre-school children living in Sweden. Part III--A longitudinal study. Risk analyses based on caries prevalence at 3 years of age and immigrant status. Swed Dent J. 1999, 23: 17-25.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Petersen PE: Global policy for improvement of oral health in the 21st century--implications to oral health research of World Health Assembly 2007, World Health Organization. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2009, 37: 1-8. 10.1111/j.1600-0528.2008.00448.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Watt R, Sheiham A: Inequalities in oral health: a review of the evidence and recommendations for action. Br Dent J. 1999, 187: 6-12.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Twetman S, Fontana M: Patient caries risk assessment. Monogr Oral Sci. 2009, 21: 91-101.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- World Health Organisation: Oral Health Surveys - Basic Methods. 1997, Geneva: World Health Organisation, 4Google Scholar
- Small area statistics unit: [http://www.sahsu.org/sahsu_studies.php#RIF]
- Beale L, Abellan JJ, Hodgson S, Jarup L: Methodologic issues and approaches to spatial epidemiology. Environ Health Perspect. 2008, 116: 1105-1110. 10.1289/ehp.10816.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- The bugs project: [http://www.mrc-bsu.cam.ac.uk/bugs]
- Greenland S: Principles of multilevel modelling. Int J Epidemiol. 2000, 29: 158-167. 10.1093/ije/29.1.158.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Stromberg U: Empirical Bayes and semi-Bayes adjustments for a vast number of estimations. Eur J Epidemiol. 2009, 24: 737-741. 10.1007/s10654-009-9393-0.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Clarke KC, McLafferty SL, Tempalski BJ: On epidemiology and geographic information systems: a review and discussion of future directions. Emerg Infect Dis. 1996, 2: 85-92. 10.3201/eid0202.960202.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Elliot PWJ, Best NG, Briggs DJ: Spatial Epidemiology: Methods and Applications. 2000, Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
- World Health Organisation: Oral Health: Action plan for promotion and integrated disease prevention.Report A60/16, 2007. [http://apps.who.int/gb/ebwha/pdf_files/WHA60/A60_16-en.pdf]
- Watt RG: Strategies and approaches in oral disease prevention and health promotion. Bull World Health Organ. 2005, 83: 711-718.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Davies GM, Jones CM, Monaghan N, Morgan MZ, Pine CM, Pitts NB, Neville JS, Rooney E: The caries experience of 5 year-old children in Scotland, Wales and England in 2007-2008 and the impact of consent arrangements. Reports of co-ordinated surveys using BASCD criteria. Community Dent Health. 2011, 28: 5-11.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Petersson LG, Twetman S, Dahlgren H, Norlund A, Holm AK, Nordenram G, Lagerlof F, Soder B, Kallestal C, Mejare I: Professional fluoride varnish treatment for caries control: a systematic review of clinical trials. Acta Odontol Scand. 2004, 62: 170-176. 10.1080/00016350410006392.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Twetman S, Axelsson S, Dahlgren H, Holm AK, Kallestal C, Lagerlof F, Lingstrom P, Mejare I, Nordenram G, Norlund A: Caries-preventive effect of fluoride toothpaste: a systematic review. Acta Odontol Scand. 2003, 61: 347-355. 10.1080/00016350310007590.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Twetman S, Petersson L, Axelsson S, Dahlgren H, Holm AK, Kallestal C, Lagerlof F, Lingstrom P, Mejare I, Nordenram G: Caries-preventive effect of sodium fluoride mouthrinses: a systematic review of controlled clinical trials. Acta Odontol Scand. 2004, 62: 223-230. 10.1080/00016350410001658.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wennhall I, Norlund A, Matsson L, Twetman S: Cost-analysis of an oral health outreach program for preschool children in a low socioeconomic multicultural area in Sweden. Swed Dent J. 2010, 34: 1-7.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6831/11/26/prepub