Skip to main content

Table 3 Quality assessment

From: An estimate of pocket closure and avoided needs of surgery after scaling and root planing with systemic antibiotics: a systematic review

Author, year of publication

Method of randomisation [+/(+)/-]

Concealment [+/(+)/-]

Blinding of the examiner [+/(+)/-]

Aimetti[36]

+

+

+

Computer generated list

Cionca[43]

+

+

+

Computer generated list

Ferres 2012[41]

+

+

+

Computer generated list

Heller[45]

+

+

+

Computer generated list

Matarazzo[40]

+

+

+

Computer generated list

Mestnik[37]

+

+

+

Computer generated table

Mombelli[24]

+

+

+

Computer generated list

Preus[99]

+

+

+

Computer generated table

Sigusch 2001[57]

(+)

-

(+)

Winkel[48]

(+)

-

+

Winkel[49]

(+)

-

+

Xajigeorgiou[50]

+

-

+

 

Randomization table

  
  1. + modality explained.
  2. (+) claimed without further explanation.
  3. - not reported.