Skip to main content

Table 5 Comparison of some staining principles in regard to their suitability for biofilm research

From: Confusion over live/dead stainings for the detection of vital microorganisms in oral biofilms - which stain is suitable?

Staining principle

Stain(s) (combinations)

Comparison with microbiological data (PE)

Concentration independency

Suitability for biofilm research

Potentially mutagenic

  

Single species in vitro

Biofilm ex vivo or in situ

   

Vital fluorescence (FDA/EB) cf. [8, 110, 112]

Fluorescein diacetate, Ethidium bromide

+

++

Proven [8, 110, 112115]

Proven (cf. Table 4)

+1

BacLight® (cf. Table 3)

Syto 9, Propidium iodide

-

-

Questionable (cf. Table 3)

Questionable (cf. Table 3)

+2

Staining according to [10, 102]

Diverse substances

?

?

Non-existing or questionable

Non-existing or questionable

?

  1. 1Proven.
  2. 2Generally to assume, partly proven.
  3. ? Partly known or not known or not available from the diverse substances.