Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 2 Papers included. Association between standardized CRA and actual caries status and/or caries prediction

From: Are standardized caries risk assessment models effective in assessing actual caries status and future caries increment? A systematic review

Authors (year) Outcome Subjects Indices Caries risk model Statistical significance Quality assessment
Children/Adolescents
Gaob, (2015) [8] CI 544 dmft Full Cariogram, CAT, CAMBRA, NUS-CRA + Good
Sundel, (2015) [21] ACS 133 dmfs/DMFS Full Cariogram + Good
Cabral, (2014) [22] ACS 150 dmft/DMFT Form based on Cariogram 7 factors ++ Poor
Kemparaj, (2014) [37] CI 200 DMFT/S Full Cariogram + Poor
Gaob, (2013) [36] CI 544 dmft Full Cariogram, CAT, CAMBRA, NUS-CRA + Good
Zukanovich, (2013) [41] CI 109 DMFS/DMFT Full Cariogram, PreViser, CAT + Fair
Campus, (2012) [35] CI 957 DFS Cariogram 7 factors + Good
Hebbal, (2012) [23] ACS 100 DMFT Full Cariogram ++ Poor
Kavvadia, (2012) [24] ACS 814 dmft Full Cariogram + Fair
Gao, (2010) [16] CI 1576 dmft Full Cariogram e Good
Peterssonc,(2010b) [39] CI 392 DMFS Full Cariogram, Cariogram 6 factors + Good
Petersson, (2010a) [40] CI 392 DMFS Full Cariogram + Good
Campus, (2009) [25] ACS 957 dmfs/DMFS Cariogram 7 factors ++ Good
Holgerson, (2009) [15] CI 125 dmfs/DMFS Full Cariogram + Fair
Twetman, (2005) [33] CI 64 DFS Full Cariogram ++ Good
Peterssona,b, (2004) [34] CI 446 DFS Full Cariogram ++ Good
Peterssonb, (2002) [32] CI 446 DMFT/S Full Cariogram + Good
Adults
Petersson, (2015) [44] CI 1295 DFT/DFTS Full Cariogram ++ Good
Carta, (2015) [31] ACS 480 ICDAS Full Cariogram ++ Good
Chaffee, (2015) [45] CI 4468 DFS CAMBRA + Good
Chang (2014) [30] CI 110 DMFT/S Cariogram 7 factors + Good
Chang and Kim, (2014) [42] ACS 102 DMFT Full Cariogram + Good
Lee, (2013) [29] ACS 80 DMFT Full Cariogram, Cariogram 7/8 factors + Fair
Petersson, (2013) [7] ACS 1295 DFT/S Cariogram 8 factors ++ Good
Celik, (2012) [43] CI 100 DMFT/S Full Cariogram + Fair
Peker, (2012) [27] ACS 90 DMFT/S Full Cariogram + Fair
Sonbul, (2008) [28] ACS 175 DMFS Full Cariogram + Good
Ruiz Miravet, (2007) [26] ACS 48 DMFT/S Full Cariogram ++ Poor
Peterssona,d, (2004) [34] CI 208 DFS Full Cariogram ++ Fair
Peterssond, (2003) [1] CI 208 DMFS /DFS/DFRS Full Cariogram ++ Good
Both Children/Adults
Giacaman, (2013) [20] ACS 180 DMFT Cariogram 7 factors Poor
Almosa, (2012) [18] ACS 89 DMFS Full Cariogram ++ Fair
Al Mulla, (2009) [19] ACS 100 DFS Full Cariogram ++ Fair
  1. ACS actual caries status, CI Caries Increment. Subjects: number of subjects at baseline
  2. Statistical significance: - = p > 0.05 + =p < 0.05; ++ = p ≤ 0.01
  3. aPetersson, (2004) reported in both children and adults and describes data in two different samples
  4. bGao, (2013) and (2015), and Petersson, (2002) and (2004) respectively reported data for the same sample of children
  5. cPetersson, (2010a) and (2010b) reported data for the same sample of children
  6. dPetersson, (2003) and (2004) reported data for the same sample of elderly people
  7. eData not obtainable from the paper