Authors (year) | Outcome | Subjects | Indices | Caries risk model | Statistical significance | Quality assessment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Children/Adolescents | ||||||
Gaob, (2015) [8] | CI | 544 | dmft | Full Cariogram, CAT, CAMBRA, NUS-CRA | + | Good |
Sundel, (2015) [21] | ACS | 133 | dmfs/DMFS | Full Cariogram | + | Good |
Cabral, (2014) [22] | ACS | 150 | dmft/DMFT | Form based on Cariogram 7 factors | ++ | Poor |
Kemparaj, (2014) [37] | CI | 200 | DMFT/S | Full Cariogram | + | Poor |
Gaob, (2013) [36] | CI | 544 | dmft | Full Cariogram, CAT, CAMBRA, NUS-CRA | + | Good |
Zukanovich, (2013) [41] | CI | 109 | DMFS/DMFT | Full Cariogram, PreViser, CAT | + | Fair |
Campus, (2012) [35] | CI | 957 | DFS | Cariogram 7 factors | + | Good |
Hebbal, (2012) [23] | ACS | 100 | DMFT | Full Cariogram | ++ | Poor |
Kavvadia, (2012) [24] | ACS | 814 | dmft | Full Cariogram | + | Fair |
Gao, (2010) [16] | CI | 1576 | dmft | Full Cariogram | e | Good |
Peterssonc,(2010b) [39] | CI | 392 | DMFS | Full Cariogram, Cariogram 6 factors | + | Good |
Petersson, (2010a) [40] | CI | 392 | DMFS | Full Cariogram | + | Good |
Campus, (2009) [25] | ACS | 957 | dmfs/DMFS | Cariogram 7 factors | ++ | Good |
Holgerson, (2009) [15] | CI | 125 | dmfs/DMFS | Full Cariogram | + | Fair |
Twetman, (2005) [33] | CI | 64 | DFS | Full Cariogram | ++ | Good |
Peterssona,b, (2004) [34] | CI | 446 | DFS | Full Cariogram | ++ | Good |
Peterssonb, (2002) [32] | CI | 446 | DMFT/S | Full Cariogram | + | Good |
Adults | ||||||
Petersson, (2015) [44] | CI | 1295 | DFT/DFTS | Full Cariogram | ++ | Good |
Carta, (2015) [31] | ACS | 480 | ICDAS | Full Cariogram | ++ | Good |
Chaffee, (2015) [45] | CI | 4468 | DFS | CAMBRA | + | Good |
Chang (2014) [30] | CI | 110 | DMFT/S | Cariogram 7 factors | + | Good |
Chang and Kim, (2014) [42] | ACS | 102 | DMFT | Full Cariogram | + | Good |
Lee, (2013) [29] | ACS | 80 | DMFT | Full Cariogram, Cariogram 7/8 factors | + | Fair |
Petersson, (2013) [7] | ACS | 1295 | DFT/S | Cariogram 8 factors | ++ | Good |
Celik, (2012) [43] | CI | 100 | DMFT/S | Full Cariogram | + | Fair |
Peker, (2012) [27] | ACS | 90 | DMFT/S | Full Cariogram | + | Fair |
Sonbul, (2008) [28] | ACS | 175 | DMFS | Full Cariogram | + | Good |
Ruiz Miravet, (2007) [26] | ACS | 48 | DMFT/S | Full Cariogram | ++ | Poor |
Peterssona,d, (2004) [34] | CI | 208 | DFS | Full Cariogram | ++ | Fair |
Peterssond, (2003) [1] | CI | 208 | DMFS /DFS/DFRS | Full Cariogram | ++ | Good |
Both Children/Adults | ||||||
Giacaman, (2013) [20] | ACS | 180 | DMFT | Cariogram 7 factors | – | Poor |
Almosa, (2012) [18] | ACS | 89 | DMFS | Full Cariogram | ++ | Fair |
Al Mulla, (2009) [19] | ACS | 100 | DFS | Full Cariogram | ++ | Fair |