Peripheral adenomatoid odontogenic tumor in a cloak of an epulis: report of a rare case

Dwivedi, Dhara; Prabhakar, Nitin; Kasetty, Sowmya; Ahuja, Rinky

doi:10.1186/s12903-019-0759-8

BMC Oral Health

Table 1 Brief review of PAOT cases published in the literature

From: Peripheral adenomatoid odontogenic tumor in a cloak of an epulis: report of a rare case

Case No.	Author and year	Age (years)	Sex	Site	Size	Disease duration	Radiographic presentation	Treatment	Recurrence	Reference No.
1.	Buchner A et al.,1987	16	F	Maxillary gingiva 1,1	NI^a	3 years	NI^a	Conservative surgery	NI^a	[12]
2.	Buchner A et al.,1987	9	M	Right Maxillary1,2	NI^a	4 years	NI^a	Conservative surgery	NI^a	[12]
3.	Buchner A et al.,1987	11	F	Left Maxillary 1,2	NI^a	NI^a	NI^a	Conservative surgery	NI^a	[12]
4.	Buchner A et al.,1987	13	F	Mandibular 1,1	NI^a	4 mo	NI^a	Conservative surgery	NI^a	[12]
5	Buchner A et al.,1987	16	F	Right Maxillary 1,2	NI^a	1mo	NI^a	Enucleation	NI^a	[12]
6.	Buchner A et al.,1987	16	F	Left Maxillary 3	NI^a	2 years	NI^a	Enucleation	NI^a	[12]
7.	Unal T et al., 1995	4	F	Right Maxillary 1, gingiva	NI^a	NI^a	NI^a	Enucleation	NI^a	[14]
8.	Unal T et al., 1995	15	M	Right maxillary 2,3 gingiva	2 × 2 × 2 cm³	9 mo	Thickening of laminadura, well-defined radiolucency below 2,3	Curettage	No	[14]
9.	Balwani SR et al., 2007	19	F	Left maxillary 2,3,4 Gingiva	3 × 2.5 × 1.5 cm³	4–5 mo	No Bone Involvement	enucleation	NI^a	[11]
10.	Panjwani S et al., 2010	18	F	Left mandibular 3,4 Gingiva	2 × 2 cm²	1 year	Well defined radiolucency	enucleation	Recurrent mass	[16]
11.	Bowers LM et al., 2012	11	M	maxillary 1,1 Gingiva	NI^a	1 year	Crestal bone loss	enucleation	Recurrent mass	[17]
12.	Kumar R et al., 2012	10	M	Right mandibular 1,2 gingiva	3 × 1.5 cm²	3 mo	Well defined radiolucency	Excision	No	[18]
13.	Lavanya N et al.,2013	12	F	Right maxillary 1 gingiva	0.8 × 1.2 × 0.5 cm³	NI^a	Well defined bone defect	Excision	No	[19]
14.	Tavares T et al., 2014	11	F	Left maxillary 1 gingiva	NI^a.	NI^a	Diffuse peri-apical radiolucency	enucleation	No	[20]
15.	Jindwani K et al., 2015	21	M	Left maxillary 1,2 gingiva	2 × 2 cm2	1 year	Well defined radiolucency	Enucleation and curettage	N	[21]
16.	Prakash SM et al.,2017	19	F	Right maxillary 2,3 gingiva	2 × 2 cm²	6 mo	Arch shaped bone loss	Excision	NI^a	[22]
17.	Janavi BR et al., 2017	21	F	Left maxillary 1,2 gingiva	1 × 1.5 cm²	6 mo	Unilocular Radio Lucency with calcific radio opaque	enucleation	No	[23]
18.	Melo VDS et al, 2014	14	M	Left maxillary gingiva 2,3	3 cm	4 mo	NI^a	enucleation	NI^a	[24]
19.	Mahato et al., 2018	27	M	Right maxillary 3 gingiva	3 × 1.5 × 1.5 cm³	1 year	No bone loss	Excision	NI^a	[25]
20.	Saito A et al., 2018	13	F	Left maxillary incisal gingiva	NI^a	3 years	insignificant absorption alveolar bone ridge	Excision and enucleation	No	[26]
Case no.	Age (years)	Sex	Site	Size	Disease duration	Symptoms	Radiographic presentation	Treatment	Recurrence
1.	16	F	Maxillary gingiva 1,1	NI^a	3 years	NI^a	NI^a	Conservative surgery	NI^a
2.	9	M	Right Maxillary1,2	NI^a	4 years	NI^a	NI^a	Conservative surgery	NI^a
3.	11	F	Left Maxillary 1,2	NI^a	NI^a	NI^a	NI^a	Conservative surgery	NI^a
4.	13	F	Mandibular 1,1	NI^a	4 mo	NI^a	NI^a	Conservative surgery	NI^a
5	16	F	Right Maxillary 1,2	NI^a	1mo	NI^a	NI^a	Enucleation	NI^a
6.	16	F	Left Maxillary 3	NI^a	2 years	NI^a	NI^a	Enucleation	NI^a
7.	4	F	Right Maxillary 1, gingiva	NI^a	NI^a	NI^a	NI^a	Enucleation	NI^a
8.	15	M	Right maxillary 2,3 gingiva	2 × 2 × 2 cm³	9 mo	NI^a	Thickening of laminadura, well-defined radiolucency below 2,3	Curettage	No
9.	19	F	Left maxillary 2,3,4 Gingiva	3 × 2.5 × 1.5 cm³	4–5 mo	Painless swelling	No Bone Involvement	enucleation	NI^a
10.	18	F	Left mandibular 3,4 Gingiva	2 × 2 cm²	1 year	Painless swelling	Well defined radiolucency	enucleation	Recurrent mass
11.	11	M	maxillary 1,1 Gingiva	NI^a	1 year	Painless swelling	Crestal bone loss	enucleation	Recurrent mass
12.	10	M	Right mandibular 1,2 gingiva	3 × 1.5 cm²	3 mo	Painless swelling	Well defined radiolucency	Excision	No
13.	12	F	Right maxillary 1 gingiva	0.8 × 1.2 × 0.5 cm³	NI^a	Painless swelling	Well defined bone defect	Excision	No
14.	11	F	Left maxillary 1 gingiva	NI^a	NI^a	Painless swelling	Diffuse peri-apical radiolucency	enucleation	No
15.	21	M	Left maxillary 1,2 gingiva	2 × 2 cm2	1 year	Painless swelling	Well defined radiolucency	Enucleation and curettage	N
16.	19	F	Right maxillary 2,3 gingiva	2 × 2 cm²	6 mo	Painless swelling	Arch shaped bone loss	Excision	NI^a
17.	21	F	Left maxillary 1,2 gingiva	1 × 1.5 cm²	6 mo	Painless swelling	Unilocular Radio Lucency with calcific radio opaque	enucleation	No
18.	14	M	Left maxillary gingiva 2,3	3 cm	4 mo	NI^a	NI^a	enucleation	NI^a
19.	27	M	Right maxillary 3 gingiva	3 × 1.5 × 1.5 cm³	1 year	Painless swelling	No bone loss	Excision	NI^a
20.	13	F	Left maxillary incisal gingiva	NI^a	3 years	Painless swelling	insignificant absorption alveolar bone ridge	Excision and enucleation	No

M male, F female, ^aNI No Information, Mo Month/months

Back to article page

ISSN: 1472-6831

Contact us

Submission enquiries: bmcoralhealth@biomedcentral.com
General enquiries: ORSupport@springernature.com