Skip to main content

Table 2 Study quality assessment. 1) stability of bisphosphonate coating, 2) ALP measurement quality, 3) description of coating procedure, 4) availability of original data, 5) surface roughness parameters, 6) contact angle measurement, 7) appropriate statistical analysis, 8) performance of at least three repetitions per experiment

From: Effect of bisphosphonate treatment of titanium surfaces on alkaline phosphatase activity in osteoblasts: a systematic review and meta-analysis

  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Study quality
Bigi et al. [40] No No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Medium
Boanini et al. [41] No No Yes Yes Yes No Yes No Medium
Boanini et al. [42] Yes No Yes Yes Yes No Yes No Medium
Hu et al. [44] Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Low
Jeon et al. [43] No Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes Medium
Kim et al. [45] Yes Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes Medium
Kim et al. [46] No Yes Yes Yes No No Yes No Medium
Moon et al. [47] Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Low
Mu et al. [48] Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No No Medium
Yoshinari et al. [49] No Yes Yes No Yes No Yes No Medium
Zheng et al. [50] Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Low