A scoping review on the links between sustainable development goal 14 and early childhood caries

Background The Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 14 addresses life below the waters, an important source of protein and contributor to global food security and economic development. Our aim was to explore possible evidence on the links between life below water and early childhood caries (ECC). Methods This scoping review identified articles on the link between life below water and caries according to the PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Three electronic databases (PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus) were systematically searched in January 2023, using specific search terms. Studies written in English, with full text available, addressing life under water, focusing on dental caries in humans, with results that can be extrapolated to control ECC in children less than 6 years of age were included in the review. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize the retrieved papers and graphical presentation was used for visualization. Results There were 224 publications retrieved of which 13 studies, published between 1960 and 2022, were included in the analysis. The papers originated from Asia (7/13), North America (3/13), Europe (1/13), and 2/13 had multi-country authorship. Also, four laboratory studies extracted agents from marine products to determine their efficacy in preventing caries formation and preventing/slowing plaque formation; four letters discussed the caries prevention potential of sea salt as a source of fluoride; and two review articles about the positive effects of extracted marine products for caries prevention. Most (11/13) studies addressed target 14.1 concerned with enriching the marine environment with nutrients and minerals; two addressed target 14.4 focused on ensuring fish stocks are within biologically sustainable levels; two addressed target 14.7 aimed at increasing the economic benefits through sustainable use of marine resources such as fisheries; and one focused on target 14.5 aimed at conserving marine areas by increasing protected areas. In addition, one ecological study assessed the association between the ecosystem and ECC. Conclusions Currently, there is little known about the impact of protection of marine and coastal ecosystem from pollution and ocean acidification on the risk of ECC. Further evidence on possible associations between life below water and ECC management is needed. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12903-023-03650-3.


Introduction
The Sustainable Development Goal 14 (SDG14) has multiple objectives centered around promoting the sustainability and well-being of marine ecosystems.These goals encompass various aspects such as reducing marine pollution, safeguarding and restoring ecosystems, mitigating ocean acidification, ensuring sustainable fishing practices, conserving coastal and marine areas, eliminating subsidies that contribute to overfishing, maximizing economic benefits from the sustainable utilization of marine resources, advancing scientific knowledge and research for ocean health, supporting small-scale fishers, and enforcing international maritime laws [1].SDG14 comprises 10 specific targets labeled as 14.1 to 14.7, 14.a, 14.b, and 14.c.Furthermore, there are 10 indicators associated with these targets.These indicators range from measuring the index of coastal eutrophication and plastic debris density (14.1.1)to assessing the progress made by countries in ratifying, accepting, and implementing legal, policy, and institutional frameworks related to oceanrelated instruments that align with international law outlined in the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.These efforts aim to ensure the conservation and sustainable utilization of oceans and their resources [2].
The Earth's oceans, which cover 71% of the planet's surface, play a significant role in providing animal protein, accounting for approximately 17% of the world's per capita consumption.However, in terms of caloric food supply, they contribute only 2% [3,4].For thousands of years, the oceans and seas have served as vital sources of protein [5], contributing to food security and economic development in numerous nations [6].Fish alone provide at least 20% of the daily animal protein intake for over 3.3 billion people worldwide [7].The vast biodiversity and undiscovered species within the oceans offer potential for the development of new oral health products and innovative compounds to combat diseases [8].Communities that rely on marine diets have been found to have lower rates of dental caries [9,10].In 2017, these communities represented approximately 37% of the global population [11].Therefore, incorporating seafood into diets as an alternative to animal protein [12,13] could potentially contribute to addressing the worldwide burden of dental caries.
The oceans and coastal areas face significant vulnerabilities due to environmental degradation, overfishing, climate change, and pollution [14].Ocean acidification has adverse effects on human access to food, oxygen, livelihoods, blue spaces, and medicines [14][15][16][17][18][19].This, in turn, increases the risks of malnutrition, poisoning, respiratory diseases, poor mental health, and the depletion of medicinal resources [20,21].Approximately 300 million people who depend on the ocean for food security and livelihoods may be impacted by this acidification [22].Preserving the ocean's ecosystem not only supports the development of products that can hinder the activities of organisms associated with the formation of tooth decay and slow down the formation of dental plaque, thereby reducing the risk of caries [23], but it also serves as a valuable source of animal protein that promotes food security [6].The preservation of ocean ecosystems can contribute to the prevention of early childhood caries (ECC) by reducing the risk of malnutrition in children, [24].This is because malnutrition is a risk factor for ECC [25,26].
ECC is as a global public health concern, affecting more than 514 million children worldwide [27].ECC is defined as the presence of both cavitated and non-cavitated tooth decay on one or more primary teeth in children under 72 months of age [28].If left untreated, ECC can result in pain, infection, contribute to malnutrition, hinder psychological development and physical growth, reduce the overall quality of life related to oral health, and in rare cases, even lead to fatalities [28][29][30][31][32].The impact of the environment on the food chain can exacerbate malnutrition.The inter-link between the impact of the environment on food chain and the resultant malnutrition, leading to a higher prevalence of caries in vulnerable marine communities, particularly those in low and lowmiddle income countries [32][33][34][35].
The association between dental caries and SDG14 (life below water) remains largely unexplored.However, it is plausible to consider that the negative impacts on the ocean and life below water could potentially elevate the risk of ECC.The objective of this scoping review was to examine existing evidence regarding the connection between life below water and the prevention and treatment of dental caries.Furthermore, the review aimed to identify potential links between life below water and ECC.

Methods
A search was performed to identify published literature in peer-reviewed journals on the association between life below water and ECC.Our scoping review was conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews guidelines (PRISMA-ScR) [36].This review was guided by the questions: (i) What is the existing evidence on the possible links between life below water and caries?and (ii) what are the possible links between life below water and ECC?

Search strategy
The initial search was conducted on three electronic databases in January 2023.The databases were PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus.The search terms and strategies used for each database are listed in Appendix 1.

Literature search and inclusion
Publications identified through the search strategy were exported to the reference management software Mendeley (version 1.19.8) and duplicates were removed.Title and abstract screening were performed independently by two researchers (AN and AI) using pre-defined inclusion and exclusion criteria.Full-text review of the remaining publications was then completed independently by four researchers (AN, AI, MOF and MET) and reference lists of potentially relevant publications were manually searched.Uncertainty regarding whether publications met the inclusion criteria was resolved via consensus among the three researchers.

Inclusion criteria
Articles were considered for inclusion if they were written in English, with full text available, addressing an organism or component of life under water and focusing on dental caries.There was no restriction by type of article, study design or time of publication.

Exclusion criteria
To answer the research question on the links between life below water and ECC, we excluded papers without data on children < 72 months of age or papers explicitly excluding this age group.Other types of data sources such as websites or books were excluded.

Data extraction
A data extraction form was developed and pilot tested.In addition to the paper identifiers (title, author, link), the following data were extracted: country, year of publication, study design, life under water component included, whether published in dental or non-dental journals.Information on the study objectives and the conclusion reached were also extracted.

Role of the funding source
The present study was funded by out-of-pocket expenses.This had no role to play in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

Analysis
Descriptive statistics as frequencies and percentages were used to summarize the categories of retrieved papers and graphical presentation was used for visualization.An analysis was conducted to identify the countries of origin of the manuscripts, the caries prevention or treatment focuses of the publication, studies that reported associations between life below waters and ECC, and the SDG14 indicators the extracted studies addressed.

Results
Figure 1 shows the process undertaken to identify relevant literature.The initial search across three databases resulted in 224 potentially relevant publications.After eliminating 12 duplicate papers, a total of 212 papers underwent screening based on their titles, abstracts, and full texts.Among these, 199 papers were excluded as they did not meet the eligibility criteria.Reasons for exclusion included being unrelated to life underwater, lacking human participants, focusing solely on individuals over 71 months of age, not addressing caries, being non-English publications, or lacking full-text availability.Out of the remaining papers, 13 studies [36][37][38][39][40][41][42][43][44][45][46][47][48][49] provided data on potential connections between life below water and caries.However, only one ecological study was found that reported an association between life below water and ECC [38].Table 1 presents further details regarding the 13 included publications.
Out of the thirteen papers analyzed, seven originated from Asian countries, including China [41][42][43]48], India [37,44], and Japan [39].Three papers were from the United States [44][45][46][47], and one paper was from Europe, specifically Norway [40].Two papers had authors from multiple countries [38,48].Among the thirteen papers, two were published in dental journals, namely Caries Research and Scandinavian Journal of Dental Research [39,40].In addition, four laboratory studies were identified.These studies focused on extracting substances from marine products, such as marine bacteria and seaweed, to evaluate their effectiveness in preventing caries formation [39,41,42], as well as preventing or slowing down plaque formation [43].Additionally, a fifth laboratory study compared the rate of dissolution between fluoroapatite (shark enamel) and hydroxyapatite (human enamel) when exposed to a high caries challenge [40].
The letters to the editor, written during the 1960 and 1970 s, focused on the potential of sea salt as a source of fluoride for caries prevention [43][44][45][46], as well as the cariogenic potential of fish flour due to its selenium content [47].However, Rao [44] found that the fluoride content in the salt was not sufficient to have anticariogenic effects.Two review articles discussed the positive effects of extracted marine products in preventing caries [48,49].Additionally, there were two observational studies: one ecological study [38] and one cross-sectional study [37], examining caries risk indicators.No cohort studies or clinical trials were identified.
The most investigated area was the use of extracted compounds from marine sources for caries prevention, including marine bacteria [41][42][43]47], bioactive compounds [49], and seaweed [39].Other areas of research focused on sea salt [43][44][45][46], fish products such as fish flour [47], and shark teeth [40].The observational studies included caries risk indicators related to the workplace environment [37] and environmental indicators such as marine protected areas, fish stock status, and the regional marine trophic index [38].
Table 1 demonstrates that most studies (11 out of 13) addressed SDG14 target 14.1, which aims to enrich the marine environment with nutrients and minerals.Two studies focused on target 14.4,aiming to ensure fish stocks are maintained at sustainable levels.Two studies examined target 14.7, aiming to increase economic benefits through the sustainable use of marine resources, particularly fisheries.One study addressed target 14.5, which involves conserving marine areas by expanding protected areas.Each study focused on one target, except for one study [38], which addressed four targets.
Figure 3 presents our proposed conceptual framework linking ECC and life under water.The evidence suggests that the connection between SDG14 and ECC can

Discussion
While our study postulates a potential link between life below water and ECC, no direct evidence supporting an association between SDG14, caries, and ECC was found.However, evidence from basic science studies suggests the use of ocean-derived substances to reduce caries risk through the production of dental products that inhibit dental bacterial biofilm formation, plaque retention, and through food sources rich in fluoride.
A scoping review was performed to survey the body of literature concerning the correlation between two significantly vital public health concerns and to identify gaps in knowledge [50].This approach aids in determining which

Table 1 (continued)
specific SDG14 targets can be advanced to a systematic review and which ones necessitate ecological analysis to generate additional evidence.One of highlights of the study is the need for ecological studies to generate preliminary evidence on the association between targets of the SDG 14 and ECC.
In addition, the findings of this scoping review suggest that effective management of the world's oceans could counterbalance the detrimental effects of climate change on oral health [51].Currently, over 30% of the world's fish stocks are overexploited [52], and ocean pollution is a global issue that destroys marine ecosystems [53] and affects atmospheric oxygen production [54].By promoting the sustainable utilization of oceans and adopting seafood-based diets [55], it is hypothesized that the risk of ECC could be reduced, leading to a decline in its global prevalence.
Most seafood naturally contains fluoride due to the presence of sodium fluoride in the ocean [56], and fluoride is known to reduce caries risk [57].Sea salts, for example, can contain as high as 40 ppm of fluoride [58].Additionally, fish and other seafood are rich sources of omega-3 fatty acids [59], which are associated with a reduced risk of active caries [60].Coastal groundwater, which is often consumed by coastal communities, is also rich in calcium and associated with a low prevalence of caries [61].The consumption of seaweeds, which is increasing in popularity [62], also provides varying amounts of fluoride based on species, environmental characteristics, water temperature, and nutrient content of seawater [63,64].Furthermore, bioactive compounds sourced from the ocean have the potential to serve as functional food ingredients for caries prevention [65].
However, the reality of caries risk is complex, and multiple factors contribute to its prevalence.Coastal indigenous communities, who heavily rely on seafood, often exhibit high ECC prevalence rates.For example, in an Indian coastal community, ECC prevalence was as high as 75% in children aged 0-4 years with an average of 4.68 decayed, filled teeth (dft), and 86.45% in children aged 5-9 years with an average dft of 5.09 [66].Another Indian coastal community reported a caries prevalence of 5.11% in children aged 5-8 years [67].These findings indicate that living in coastal areas alone, without considering broader preventive oral health behaviors, food habits, lifestyle, and other cultural and socioeconomic contexts, may not necessarily result in low ECC prevalence.Many coastal communities face high levels of poverty, limited access to oral health services, low oral health awareness, and habits such as infrequent toothbrushing and high consumption of sugary foods [68,69].Therefore, future studies should consider conducting comparative evaluations of marine-dependent communities while controlling for possible confounders.
As shown in Table 2, the profile of ECC prevalence in countries with high seafood consumption does not consistently demonstrate a trend toward low caries prevalence.This finding suggests that country-level factors may influence caries risk in primary dentition.For instance, Japan has achieved significant improvements in oral health over the years through its oral health system [70], while China has faced neglect in oral health care [71], and countries like Myanmar, India, Vietnam, and Malaysia have various challenges in terms of investment, policy implementation, and equitable access to public healthcare [71][72][73][74][75]. Consequently, SDG14 may complement the efforts of other SDGs to have a measurable impact on ECC prevalence through the development of data-driven strategies based on legislation, policies, and technology [76].
Table 2 also highlights the high consumption of fish in Asia, with seven out of the top ten fish-consuming nations located in the region.Similarly, a significant number of publications on caries and SDG14 originate from Asia.Despite the potential benefits that oceanic products offer in terms of anti-cariogenic properties, ECC prevalence remains extremely high in this region, particularly in Southeast Asia [24,79].The study by Folayan et al. [38], however, suggests that the ocean alone may not be sufficient in reducing ECC, as the associations between marine ecosystem variables and ECC were not significant, and the effect size was small.Rao [44] also indicates that the fluoride content in sea salt may not provide adequate protection against caries.Therefore, future studies should aim to comprehend how multiple factors may limit the effectiveness of oceanic resources in reducing caries risk, including ECC.Furthermore, ocean acidification, which leads to airway irritants and discomfort, can worsen asthma symptoms, and decrease pulmonary function [80].Respiratory disorders directly increase the risk of ECC [81,82], or indirectly through a higher likelihood of developing enamel defects [83,84], often caused using asthma medications [85].Additionally, the loss of livelihood due to the collapse of the fishing industry may diminish the fundamental "nature-connectedness" that promotes mental health [85][86][87][88].Poor mental health is associated with a higher risk of caries, partly due to neglecting oral hygiene and partly due to xerostomia resulting from antidepressant use [89].Similarly, parental mental health disorders are linked to an increased ECC risk in preschool children [90].
This scoping review has some limitations.Firstly, it did not include literature from databases not covered in the review or studies published in languages other than Fig. 3 The conceptual framework of early childhood caries and life under water (SDG14) indicating the publications, and the mechanism by which they are linked with behavioural, biological and socioeconomical risk factors for caries.These links to caries can also be linked to early childhood caries 14 − 1 Reduce marine pollution 14 − 2 Protect and restore ecosystems 14 − 3 Reduce Ocean acidification 14 − 4 Sustainable fishing 14 − 5 Conserve coastal and marine areas 14 − 6 End subsidies contributing to overfishing 14 − 7 Increase the economic benefits from sustainable use of marine resources 14-A Increase scientific knowledge, research, and technology for ocean health 14-B Support small scale fishers 14-C Implement and enforce international sea law English.This may have resulted in an underestimation of publications examining the links between SDG14, caries, and ECC.Additionally, we did not explore the existence of dental products currently available in the market that utilize underwater components to control and prevent ECC.This is an area that could be explored in future studies.Despite these limitations, this scoping review is the first to provide an overview of research on the link between SDG14 and ECC, identifying research gaps and emphasizing the need to explore the interconnection between SDG14 and other caries prevention strategies to mitigate the risk of ECC.

Conclusion
In conclusion, our study highlights the limited knowledge regarding the impact of protecting marine and coastal ecosystems from pollution and ocean acidification on the risk of ECC.Further evidence is required to understand the potential association between bodies of water, marine life, and the global prevalence of ECC, as well as to develop effective ECC management strategies.

Fig. 1
Fig.1Resources included in the scoping review based on the PRISMA 2020 method[36]

Fig. 2
Fig. 2 Number of papers on SDG14 related elements and ECC over time

Table 1
Characteristics of the studies included in the scoping review (n = 13)