Skip to main content

Table 1 The basic information and data of 13 studies in the meta-analysis

From: Association between 20q12 rs13041247 polymorphism and risk of nonsyndromic cleft lip with or without cleft palate: a meta-analysis

First author/Year

Country

Ethnicity

Study design

Source of

Genotyping

Study size

P for HWE

Case

Control

Case

Control

Controls

method

case/control

in controls

CC/CT/TT

CC/CT/TT

C/T

C/T

Enmin Huang 2012 [9]

China

East Asian

Case-control

PB

Mass spectrometry

300/354

0.689

33/149/118

70/179/105

215/385

319/389

Lang Feifei 2017 [10]

China

East Asian

Case-control

PB

TaqMan

162/178

> 0.05

43/69/50

22/85/71

155/169

129/227

Xiaoqing Yin 2018 [6]

China

East Asian

Case-control

PB

TaqMan

1278/1295

0.331

202/606/458

270/640/374

1010/1522

1180/1388

Zhongwei Z 2013 [11]

China

East Asian

Case-control

PB

PCR-RFLP

369/433

0.99

62/162/49

145/211/77

286/260

501/365

Pan 2011 [12]

China

East Asian

Case-control

HB

PCR

367/382

0.26

50/159/158

89/202/91

259/475

380/384

Mi 2014 [13]

China

East Asian

Case-control

HB

Mini-sequencing

324/343

0.956

78/162/84

63/168/112

318/330

294/392

Sun 2015 (I) [14]

China

East Asian

Case-control

PB

Affymetrix Genome-Wide

504/455

0.991

77/250/203

110/258/151

404/656

478/560

Sun 2015(II) [14]

China

East Asian

Case-control

PB

Affymetrix Genome-Wide

384/793

0.977

74/189/121

185/399/216

337/431

769/831

Gurramkond 2015 [5]

Indian

India’s

Case-control

HB

KASPar

173/176

0.85

4/65/75

20/77/79

73/215

117/235

Reiter 2015 [15]

Germany

Caucasian

Case-control

PB

PCR

119/383

0.843

20/46/53

46/176/161

86/152

268/498

Clarissa Fontoura 2012 [16]

Brazil

Caucasian

Case-control

HB

TaqMan

400/412

0.51

38/165/182

42/180/166

241/529

264/512

Kerstin U.Ludwig 2014 [8]

Mexico

Mayan

Case-control

PB

PCR-RFLP

153/337

0.192

15/67/66

51/139/129

97/199

241/397

Do Rego Borges 2015 [7]

Brazil

Brazilian

Case-control

PB

PCR

293/352

0.964

29/100/164

25/137/190

158/428

187/517

Butali 2011 [17]

Nigerian

African

Case-control

PB

PCR

88/88

0.88

54/30/4

47/35/6

138/38

129/47

  1. Abbreviations: HWE, Hardy-Weinberg equiibrium; PCR: polymerase chain reaction; RFLP: restriction fragment length polymorphism; KASPar, allele-specific amplification followed by fluorescence detection; PB, population-based; HB, hospital-based; (I) Huaxi Cohort; (II) Nanjing Cohort