Skip to main content

Table 2 Quality assessment scores for the studies included in this meta-analysis

From: Association between 20q12 rs13041247 polymorphism and risk of nonsyndromic cleft lip with or without cleft palate: a meta-analysis

First Author (year)

Selection

Comparability

Exposure

Total Points

Enmin Huang 2012 [9]

****

*

***

8

Lang Feifei 2017 [10]

***

*

***

7

Xiaoqing Yin 2018 [6]

****

**

***

9

ZHOU Zhongwei 2013 [11]

***

*

***

7

Pan 2011 [12]

***

**

***

8

Mi 2014 [13]

***

**

***

8

Sun 2015 (I) (II) [14]

****

*

***

8

Gurramkond 2015 [5]

***

**

***

8

Reiter 2015 [15]

***

*

***

7

Clarissa Fontoura 2012 [16]

***

*

***

7

Kerstin U.Ludwig 2014 [8]

****

–

***

7

Do Rego Borges 2015 [7]

****

–

***

7

Butali 2011 [17]

***

*

***

7

  1. Each asterisk means one point