Table 5 Detail of the included studies of the static navigation system
Author | Study design | Sample (implant) | Clinical condition | Pre-operative planning | Surgical procedure | Evaluation method | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arch (implant) | Edentulisn (implant) | Scanning | Software | Flap method (implant) | Guide support (implant) | Protocol | |||||
Assche et al., 2010 [30] | Pros | 19 | Max (17) Man (2) | Partial | No | Procera® | NR | Tooth | Fully | Radiographic | |
Arisan et al., 2010 [31] | Retro | 279 | Max Man | Partial Complete | No | Stent CAD® SimPlant Pro® | Flap-Flapless | Tooth (95) Mucosa (97) Bone (87) | Partial Fully | Radiographic | |
Cassetta et al., 2011 [32] | Retro | 111 | Max (68) Man (43) | Partial (17) Complete (94) | No | Simplant® | Flap (18) Flapless (93) | Tooth (8) Bone (18) Mucosa (85) | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cassetta et al., 2012 [33] | Retro | 116 | Max (67) Man (49) | Partial (28) Complete (88) | No | Simplant® | Flap (22) Flapless (94) | Tooth (15) Mucosa (88) Bone (13) | NR | Radiographic | |
Pettersson et al., 2012 [19] | Retro | 139 | Max (89) Man (50) | Complete | No | Procera® | Flapless | Bone | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cassetta et al., 2012 [34] | Retro | 95 | Max | Complete | No | Simplant® | Flapless | Mucosa | NR | Radiographic | |
D'Haese et al., 2012 [18] | Pro | 77 | Max (77) | Complete | No | Astra Tech AB® | Flapless | Mucosa | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cassetta et al., 2013 [35] | Retro | 111 | NR | Partial Complete | No | Simplant® | Flap-Flapless | Tooth Mucosa Bone | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cassetta et al., 2013 [36] | Retro | 227 | Max (135) Man (92) | Partial (45) Complete (182) | NR | Simplant® | Flap (40) Flapless (187) | Tooth Mucosa Bone | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cassetta et al., 2013 [37] | Retro | 129 | Max (78) Man (51) | Partial (17) Complete (112) | No | Simplant® | Flap (18) Flapless (111) | Tooth (8) Mucosa (103) Bone (18) | NR | Radiographic | |
Van de Wiele et al., 2014 [38] | Pro | 75 | Max-Man | Complete | No | Simplant® | Flapless | Mucosa | NR | Radiographic | |
Testori et al., 2014 [39] | Pro | 117 | Max-Man | Complete | NR | Simplant® | NR | Mucosa Bone Tooth | NR | Radiographic | |
Verhamme et al., 2015 [40] | Pro | 150 | Max (150) | Complete | No | Procera® | NR | Mucosa | NR | Radiographic | |
Alzoubi et al., 2016 [41] | Retro | 40 | Max-Man | Partial | IOS EOS | Anatomage® | NR | Tooth | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cassetta and Bellardini, 2017 [42] | RCT | C: 33 T: 37 | Max-Man | Complete | No | 3Diagnosys® | Flapless | Mucosa | Fully | Radiographic | |
Horwitz et al., 2017 [43] | Case series | 18 | Max-Man | Partial | NR | SMOP® | Flap | Tooth | Fully | Radiographic | |
Albiero et al., 2017 [44] | Case series | 60 | Max (42) Man (18) | Complete | NR | Simplant® | Flapless | Mucosa | Fully | Radiographic | |
Schnutenhaus et al., 2018 [45] | Retro | 122 | Max (48) Man (74) | Partial | EOS | SMOP® | Flap-Flapless | Tooth | Fully | Non-radiographic | |
Schnutenhaus et al., 2018 [46] | Pro | 20 | Max (10) Man (10) | Partial | EOS | SMOP® | Flap-Flapless | Tooth | Fully | Non-radiographic | |
Derksen et al., 2019 [21] | Pro | 145 | Max (66) Man (79) | Partial | IOS | CoDiagnostix® | Flap (111) Flapless (34) | Tooth | Fully | Non-radiographic | |
Albiero et al., 2019 [47] | Retro | 114 | Max (88) Man (26) | Partial Complete | No | Simplant® | Flapless | Mucosa | Fully | Radiographic | |
Schelbert et al., 2019 [48] | Retro | 26 | Max (11) Man (15) | Partial | IOS | SMOP® | Flap | Tooth Mucosa | Fully | Radiographic | |
Zhou et al., 2019 [49] | Pro | 74 | Max-Man | Partial Complete | IOS | GuideMia® | Flap | Tooth Mucosa | Partial | Radiographic | |
Skjerven et al., 2019 [50] | Pro | 27 | Max (21) Man (6) | Partial | IOS | Implant Studio® | Flap | Tooth | Fully | Non-radiographic | |
Monaco et al., 2020 [51] | Retro | 120 | Max (61) Man (59) | Partial Complete | IOS | CoDiagnostix® | Flap (96) Flapless (24) | Tooth mucosa | Fully | Non-radiographic | |
Suksod et al., 2020 [52] | Pro | 20 | Max (16) Man (4) | Partial | NR | CoDiagnostix® | Flap | Tooth | Partial | Radiographic | |
Kiatkroekkrai et al., 2020 [22] | RCT | C: 30 T: 30 | Max (40) Man (20) | Partial | IOS EOS | CoDiagnostix® | Flap-Flapless | Tooth | Fully | Radiographic | |
Chai et al., 2020 [53] | Pro | 44 | Max (21) Man (23) | Complete | EOS | Organical® Dental Implant® | Flapless | Mucosa | Fully | Radiographic | |
Kivovics et al., 2020 [54] | RCT | C: 22 T: 18 | Max-Man | Complete | EOS | CoDiagnostix® | Flap | Mucosa | Partial | Radiographic | |
Cassetta et al., 2020 [8] | Pro | 56 | Max-Man | Partial (23) Complete (33) | NR | 3Diagnosys® | NR | Tooth Mucosa | Fully | Radiographic | |
Zhang et al., 2021 [55] | Pro | 30 | NR | Partial | IOS | Implant Studio® | Flap | Tooth | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cunha et al., 2021 [56] | Pro | 61 | Max (36) Man (25) | Complete | No | P3Dental® | Flapless (61) | Mucosa (61) | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cho et al., 2021 [57] | Pro | 48 | Max (39) Man (9) | Partial | IOS | Blus Sky Plan III® | NR | Tooth | Partial | Radiographic | |
Gargallo et al., 2022 [58] | Pro | 60 | Max (8) Man (52) | Partial | IOS | CoDiagnostix® | Flap | Tooth | Fully | Radiographic | |
Cristache et al., 2021 [59] | RCT | C: 56 T: 55 | Max (46) Man (65) | Partial | IOS EOS | R2gate® | Flapless | Tooth | Fully | Non-radiographic | |
Han et al., 2021 [60] | Retro | 74 | Max (23) Man (33) | Partial Complete | EOS | BenQ AB® | NR | Tooth (28) Mucosa (28) | Partial Fully | Radiographic | |
Schnutenhaus et al., 2021 [61] | Pro | 20 | Max (8) Man (12) | Partial (20) | EOS | SMOP® | Flap | Tooth | Fully | Non-radiographic | |
Matsumura et al., 2021 [62] | Retro | 188 | Max-Man | Partial | NR | CoDiagnostix® | NR | Tooth | Fully Partial | Radiographic | |
Souza et al., 2022 [63] | Retro | 54 | Max-Man | Partial | EOS | CoDiagnostix® | Flap-Flapless | Tooth Mucosa | Fully | Non-radiographic | |
Sun et al., 2022 [64] | RCT | C: 15 T: 15 | Max (14) Man (16) | Partial | IOS | CoDiagnostix® | NR | Tooth | Partial | Non-radiographic | |
Orban et al., 2022 [65] | RCT | C: 20 T: 20 | Max | Partial | NR | NR | Flap | Tooth Mucosa | Partial | Non-radiographic | |
Ngamprasertkit et al., 2022 [66] | RCT | C: 15 T: 15 | Max-Man | Partial | IOS | Planmeca Romexis® | Flap | Tooth | Partial Fully | Radiographic | |
Zhu et al., 2022 [67] | Retro | 191 | Max (91) Man (100) | Complete | No | 6D Planning® | Flapless | Mucosa | Partial | Radiographic | |