- Research article
- Open Access
- Open Peer Review
In vitro effect of fluoride oral hygiene tablets on artificial caries lesion formation and remineralization in human enamel
© Gängler et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2009
- Received: 27 April 2009
- Accepted: 2 October 2009
- Published: 2 October 2009
Aim of this in-vitro-study was to assess the remineralization potential of a tooth cleaning tablet with different fluoride content.
Twenty three caries free impacted third molars were examined, enamel surfaces were wax coated leaving two 3 × 4 mm windows for exposure to demineralization/remineralization cycles. The teeth were randomly assigned to 4 groups of 5 control and 6 experimental teeth. Demineralization by standardised HEC-gel, pH 4.7 at 37°C for 72 h, was alternated by rinsing in remineralization solution, pH 7.0 at 37°C for 72 h, total challenge time 432 h. The negative control group N was treated during remineralization cycles with saline; positive control group P was treated with remineralization solution; experimental group D1 was exposed to remineralization solution containing Denttabs®-tablets with 1450 ppm F; experimental group D2 was exposed to remineralization solution and Denttabs®-tablets with 4350 ppm F. Each tooth was cut into serial sections and analyzed by polarized light microscopy for assessment of the different zones of white-spot lesions in 3 representative sections. Statistical analysis was based on the Mann-Whitney-Test.
Both control groups N(-) and P(+) exhibited characteristic white-spot lesions. The remineralization and the demineralization inhibition of the lesions increased considerably from N<P < D1<D2. Denttabs®-2 administration showed partial/total remineralization including lamination and/or disappearance of the body of the lesion. The different results of all 4 groups were statistically highly significant (p < 0.01) with both tests.
Based on these results the novel Denttabs® formulation represents a highly effective oral hygiene product and the remineralization is correlated to the fluoride content.
- Negative Control Group
- Tooth Brushing
- Fluoride Content
- Human Enamel
- High Fluoride Concentration
Fluoride dentifrices are widely used, and it is experimentally well established that they contribute to remineralization of incipient caries lesions in human and bovine enamel [1–3]. In the last decade many questions have been raised on the bioavailability of fluoride in oral fluids, and new formulations with different fluoride content are under investigation. Recently it has been demonstrated that elevated fluoride products enhance remineralization of advanced bovine enamel lesions .
On the other hand, the long or even life long presence of the human dentition combined with dietary influences and individual tooth brushing habits may lead to the risk of erosive and/or abrasive lesions of enamel and especially of root dentin. It was therefore the aim of the development of an oral hygiene agent in tablet form to increase the fluoride availability in oral fluids and to substitute the abrading effect of many traditional toothpastes by a polishing action due to microcrystalline hydroxyethyl cellulose. The resulting product (Denttabs®, Prodentum, Berlin, Germany) is rapidly dissolved in saliva, and the fluoride bioavailability immediatedly after tooth brushing and 10 minutes after tooth brushing is higher (Median 165.2 ppm F-) compared to a conventional dentifrice foam/saliva mixture (Median 123.7 ppm F-) (Naumova et al., Fluoride bioavailability in saliva after using DENTTABS® compared to dentifrice, submitted).
The oral hygiene tablets have also been clinically tested, and the plaque reducing efficiency was similar to a conventional dentifrice in a field study as well as in a controlled clinical trial .
The question remained whether an additional fluoride enhancement of remineralization could be expected for an elevated fluoride content of 4350 ppm versus 1450 ppm in Denttabs®. The higher fluoride concentration in 0.33 g tablets is equal to 1450 ppm F- per 1.00 g toothpaste as the common amount per application.
It was therefore the aim of this study to assess the relative efficiency of two fluoride treatments on demineralization and remineralization of human dental enamel in a pH cycling model. Qualitative and semi-quantitative polarized light microscopy of serial ground sections was used to detect the morphology of lesions and to assess the pore volume of de- and remineralization. Polarized light microscopy has been chosen as the method to determine the morphology of the different lesions because it allows distinguishing between the different lesion zones. Also the extent of the different lesions zones could be measured exactly.
Overall experimental design
pH 4.7, 37°C
pH 7.0, 37°C
Remin. solution + Denttabs® 1450 ppm F-
pH 7.0, 37°C
Remin. solution + Denttabs® 4350 ppm F-
pH 7.0, 37°C
pH-cycling conditions were chosen to create advanced artificial enamel lesions on natural smooth surfaces. Each cycle was scheduled for 3 days and was repeated 6 times. The experimental period of pH-cycling lasted therefore 18 days. After demineralization and remineralization (except for the negative control group) the specimens were rinsed in distilled water to remove excess treatment gel solution. Demineralization gel contained 1.5 mM CaCl2, 0.9 mM KH2PO4, 150 mM KCl, 0.1 M sodium acetate buffer, 30 mM acetate in hydroxyehtyl cellulose. The pH was adjusted to 4.7 and controlled before and after each 3 day cycle .
Remineralization solutions were comprised of 1.5 mM CaCl2, 0.9 mM KH2PO4, and 150 mM KCl at pH 7.0, again controlled before and after each 3 day cycle.
The experimental scheme is presented in Table 1. The negative control group N of 5 teeth with10 lesions underwent demineralization cycles only and was kept during the remineralization cycles in saline. The positive control group P of 6 teeth with 12 lesions was remineralized in the specified solution without fluoride content. The 2 experimental groups (D1 and D2) of 6 teeth with 12 lesions each were exposed to remineralization solution containing Denttabs® with 1450 ppm F- (D1) or Denttabs® with 4350 ppm F- (D2). The oral hygiene tablets contain fluoride from NaF, and the other ingredients according to INCI are microcrystalline hydroxyethyl cellulose, hydrated silica, sodium hydrogen carbonate, sodium laurylsulfate, ascorbic acid, magnesium stearate, aspartame and mint flavor.
The tablets were suspended in the remineralization solution with a ratio of one tablet per 5 ml solution to simulate the maximal bioavailability of fluoride immediately after brushing (Naumova et al., Fluoride bioavailability in saliva after using DENTTABS® compared to dentifrice, submitted).
Polarized light microscopy (PLM)
After removal of the wax coatings standardized micro photos of all lesions at 10× magnification were taken. Before further processing the roots were removed. All teeth were then dehydrated in graded alcohol and embedded in Technovit 9100 (Kulzer, Weinheim, Germany). Serial ground sections were cut with a saw microtome (LEICA CM 1900, Leica, Wetzlar, Germany) with a thickness of 80 μm in corono-apical direction. Three ground sections per tooth representing two approximal and one middle area of the lesions were used for qualitative and semi quantitative assessment of the lesion morphology.
The qualitative assessment of lesion zone characteristics included the homogeneity of the superficial zone and of the body of the lesion representing the area-specific mineral loss due to changing birefringence of different pore volumes imbibited with Technovit 9100. In addition the presence of laminations in the body of the lesion and the detectable translucent zone was analyzed.
For quantitative analysis the extent of the respective caries-like lesion zones (surface zone, body of the lesion, translucent zone) was measured in μm integrating their maximal and minimal values and continuing in equal distances over the whole lesion until 10 measurements were assessed. Three sections of each lesion were selected for the measurements.
Because the data showed no normal distribution statistical analysis was done using the non parametric Mann-Whitney U test and SPSS 14 as computer program. Significance was determined at p < 0.05.
Qualitative PLM assessment
Qualitative polarized light microscopy with characteristic features of artificial enamel lesions, percentage of serial ground sections
Surface zone homogeneous
Body of the lesion homogeneous
Presence of laminations
Detection of translucent zone
Quantitative PLM assessment
Extent of lesion zones in μm in the different groups
Body of lesion
Previous studies of the natural history of human enamel caries lesions in deciduous and permanent teeth using three dimensional features of polarized light microscopy have contributed to the understanding of the dynamics of caries progression [7–9]. The same methodology including the 3D-reconstruction of artificial caries-like lesions and the assessment of the volume of the body of the lesion has been exploited for testing various toothpastes  and under different pH conditions . The size, volume and configuration of these artificial lesions differ greatly from the typical characteristics of natural early onset, arrested or progressing lesions. However, the lesion zones in polarized light according to Gustafson  are the same, and artificially created caries-like lesions are widely used to detect the regulation of mineral deposition and dissolution  and to determine the relative efficiency of fluoride toothpastes under pH cycling conditions .
The data of the present study confirm the effects of fluoride on demineralization and remineralization of human enamel. It was found that the demineralization regime over 18 days created advanced caries-like lesions with homogeneous surface zones and high pore volumes of the body of the lesion. The extent was around 200 μm and different from the positive control teeth in pH cycling with standard remineralization solution with a depth around 120 μm.
The fluoride availability from 1450 ppm containing oral hygiene tablets in the remineralization solution was equal to 96 ppm (one 0.33 g tablet per 5 ml solution) what corresponds to the fluoride bioavailability from a conventional 1400 ppm F- dentifrice in saliva immediately after tooth brushing (Naumova et al., Fluoride bioavailability in saliva after using DENTTABS® compared to dentifrice, submitted). The elevated fluoride availability from the 4350 ppm containing oral hygiene tablets was 287 ppm what again simulates the bioavailability in saliva after tooth brushing with Denttabs®.
In both experimental groups of teeth the mineral loss decreased tremendously and the different extent of the body of the lesion was highly significant. The lesion depth of the conventional fluoride group D1 was around 70 μm, and the body of the lesion in the elevated fluoride group D2 was even smaller around 40 μm. The translucent zone did not differ in control groups and in the conventional fluoride group D1. However, this zone of demineralizing front was significantly more extended in the elevated fluoride group D2 representing mainly inhibition of demineralization in the inner part of the lesion in contrast to mineral uptake in the outer part of the human enamel lesion. There was also a sharp increase of laminations in close to half of all sections. In contrast, laminations were very rare in the remineralization group with no fluoride, and they were completely absent in the teeth with demineralization cycles only. In natural white-spot lesions laminations are attributed to short or long-lasting periods of different caries challenge [12, 13]. Ten Cate et al.  showed that mineral uptake and loss occur at different depths within the lesions, and they assumed that fluoride-induced recrystallization has made the crystallites larger and less soluble in acid. Our PLM features confirm this hypothesis, and they demonstrate a clear dose response. The marked difference in the mineral structure of artificial incipient lesions, compared to that of sound enamel, gives rise to the phenomenon of simultaneous remineralization and demineralization. Quantitative microradiographic studies after application of higher fluoride concentration showed an increase in remineralization in the outer lesion and a decrease in demineralization in the inner part, resulting in a significant increase in mineral gain . It has recently been discussed that with elevated external F- levels, the F- gradient might be higher, driving the fluoride deeper into the advanced lesion, in spite of the F- diffusion being slowed by adsorption onto and reaction with hydroxyapatite crystallites . According to these results higher concentrations of fluoride are required to prevent the progression of artificial caries-like lesions. Therefore, the F- bioavailability in oral fluids simulated by the presented study design plays a significant role in enhancing remineralization of enamel caries lesions.
In conclusion, remineralization and demineralization of advanced human enamel caries-like lesions were found to benefit from higher fluoride concentrations (4350 ppm versus 1450 ppm) during oral hygiene tablet treatment in a pH cycling model.
The authors thank Mrs. Susanne Haussmann for her technical assistance.
- Arnold WH, Dorow A, Langenhorst S, Gintner Z, Banoczy J, Gaengler P: Effect of fluoride toothpastes on enamel demineralization. BMC Oral Health. 2006, 6: 8-10.1186/1472-6831-6-8.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- ten Cate JM, Exterkate RA, Buijs MJ: The relative efficacy of fluoride toothpastes assessed with pH cycling. Caries Res. 2006, 40 (2): 136-141. 10.1159/000091060.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yamazaki H, Litman A, Margolis HC: Effect of fluoride on artificial caries lesion progression and repair in human enamel: regulation of mineral deposition and dissolution under in vivo-like conditions. Arch Oral Biol. 2007, 52 (2): 110-120. 10.1016/j.archoralbio.2006.08.012.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- ten Cate JM, Buijs MJ, Miller CC, Exterkate RA: Elevated fluoride products enhance remineralization of advanced enamel lesions. J Dent Res. 2008, 87 (10): 943-947. 10.1177/154405910808701019.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Böshagen C, Eifler H, Gängler P: Klinische Bewertung der Mundhygieneeffektivität einer Zahnputztablette. Zahnarzt und Praxis. 2005, 8: 420-424.Google Scholar
- Gangler P, Noren JG, Hoyer I, Bjarnason S, Kraft U, Odelius H, Wucherpfennig G: Reactivity of young and old human enamel to demineralization. Scand J Dent Res. 1993, 101 (6): 345-349.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Arnold WH, Gaengler P, Sabov K, Schmitz I, Gedalia I, Steinberg D: Induction and 3D reconstruction of caries-like lesions in an experimental dental plaque biofilm model. J Oral Rehabil. 2001, 28 (8): 748-754. 10.1046/j.1365-2842.2001.00755.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Arnold WH, Gaengler P, Saeuberlich E: Distribution and volumetric assessment of initial approximal caries lesions in human premolars and permanent molars using computer-aided three-dimensional reconstruction. Arch Oral Biol. 2000, 45 (12): 1065-1071. 10.1016/S0003-9969(00)00074-1.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Arnold WH, Konopka S, Kriwalsky MS, Gaengler P: Morphological analysis and chemical content of natural dentin carious lesion zones. Ann Anat. 2003, 185 (5): 419-424. 10.1016/S0940-9602(03)80099-7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Arnold WH, Haase A, Hacklaender J, Gintner Z, Banoczy J, Gaengler P: Effect of pH of amine fluoride containing toothpastes on enamel remineralization in vitro. BMC Oral Health. 2007, 7: 14-10.1186/1472-6831-7-14.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Gustafson G: The histopathology of caries of human dental enamel with special reference to the division of the lesion into zones. Acta Odontol Scand. 1957, 15: 13-55. 10.3109/00016355709041091.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Arnold WH, Cerman M, Neuhaus K, Gaengler P: Volumetric assessment and quantitative element analysis of the effect of fluoridated milk on enamel demineralization. Arch Oral Biol. 2003, 48 (6): 467-473. 10.1016/S0003-9969(03)00087-6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Driessens FC, Theuns HM, Heijligers HJ, Borggreven JM: Microradiography and electron microprobe analysis of some natural white and brown spot enamel lesions with and without laminations. Caries Res. 1986, 20 (5): 398-405.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6831/9/25/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.